| # | Read | Year | Title | With |
| 1 |  | 1897 | The Little Glass Bottle | |
| 2 |  | 1898 | The Secret Cave or John Lees Adventure | |
| 3 |  | 1898 | The Mystery of the Grave-Yard | |
| 4 |  | 1902 | The Mysterious Ship (short version) | |
| 4 |  | 1902 | The Mysterious Ship (long version) | |
| 5 |  | 1905 | The Beast in the Cave | |
| 6 |  | 1908 | The Alchemist | |
| 7 |  | 1917 | The Tomb | |
| 8 |  | 1917 | Dagon | |
| 9 |  | 1917 | A Reminiscence of Dr Samuel Johnson | |
| 10 |  | 1917 | Sweet Ermengarde | |
| 11 |  | 1918 | Polaris | |
| 12 |  | 1918 | The Green Meadow | Winifred V Jackson |
| 13 |  | 1919 | Beyond the Wall of Sleep | |
| 14 |  | 1919 | Memory | |
| 15 |  | 1919 | Old Bugs | |
| 16 |  | 1919 | The Transition of Juan Romero | |
| 17 |  | 1919 | The White Ship | |
| 18 |  | 1919 | The Doom That Came to Sarnath | |
| 19 |  | 1919 | The Statement of Randolph Carter | |
| 20 |  | 1920 | The Terrible Old Man | |
| 21 |  | 1920 | The Tree | |
| 22 |  | 1920 | The Cats of Ulthar | |
| 23 |  | 1920 | The Temple | |
| 24 |  | 1920 | Facts concerning the Late Arthur Jermyn and His Family | |
| 25 |  | 1920 | The Street | |
| 26 |  | 1920 | Poetry and the Gods | Anna Helen Crofts |
| 27 |  | 1920 | Celephaïs | |
| 28 |  | 1920 | From Beyond | |
| 29 |  | 1920 | Nyarlathotep | |
| 30 |  | 1920 | The Picture in the House | |
| 31 |  | 1920 | The Crawling Chaos | Winifred V Jackson |
| 32 |  | 1920 | Ex Oblivione | |
| 33 |  | 1921 | The Nameless City | |
| 34 |  | 1921 | The Quest of Iranon | |
| 35 |  | 1921 | The Moon-Bog | |
| 36 |  | 1921 | The Outsider | |
| 37 |  | 1921 | The Other Gods | |
| 38 |  | 1921 | The Music of Erich Zann | |
| 39 |  | 1921 | Herbert West - Reanimator | |
| 40 |  | 1922 | Hypnos | |
| 41 |  | 1922 | What the Moon Brings | |
| 42 |  | 1922 | Azathoth | |
| 43 |  | 1922 | The Horror at Martin's Beach | Sonia H Greene |
| 44 |  | 1922 | The Hound | |
| 45 |  | 1922 | The Lurking Fear | |
| 46 |  | 1923 | The Rats in the Walls | |
| 47 |  | 1923 | The Unnamable | |
| 48 |  | 1923 | Ashes | C M Eddy, Jr |
| 49 |  | 1923 | The Ghost-Eater | C M Eddy, Jr |
| 50 |  | 1923 | The Loved Dead | C M Eddy, Jr |
| 51 |  | 1923 | The Festival | |
| 52 |  | 1924 | Deaf, Dumb, and Blind | C M Eddy, Jr |
| 53 |  | 1924 | Under the Pyramids | Harry Houdini |
| 54 |  | 1924 | The Shunned House | |
| 55 |  | 1925 | The Horror at Red Hook | |
| 56 |  | 1925 | He | |
| 57 |  | 1925 | In the Vault | |
| 57 |  | 1925 | In the Vault | |
| 58 |  | 1926 | The Descendant | |
| 59 |  | 1926 | Cool Air | |
| 60 |  | 1926 | The Call of Cthulhu | |
| 61 |  | 1926 | Two Black Bottles | Wilfred Blanch Talman |
| 62 |  | 1926 | Pickman's Model | |
| 63 |  | 1926 | The Silver Key | |
| 64 |  | 1926 | The Strange High House in the Mist | |
| 65 |  | 1926 | The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath | |
| 66 |  | 1927 | The Case of Charles Dexter Ward | |
| 67 |  | 1927 | The Colour out of Space | |
| 68 |  | 1927 | The Very Old Folk | |
| 69 |  | 1927 | The Thing in the Moonlight | |
| 70 |  | 1927 | The Last Test | Adolphe de Castro |
| 71 |  | 1927 | History of the Necronomicon | |
| 72 |  | 1928 | The Curse of Yig | Zealia Bishop |
| 73 |  | 1928 | Ibid | |
| 74 |  | 1928 | The Dunwich Horror | |
| 75 |  | 1929 | The Electric Executioner | Adolphe de Castro |
| 76 |  | 1929 | The Mound | Zealia Bishop |
| 77 |  | 1930 | Medusa's Coil | Zealia Bishop |
| 78 |  | 1930 | The Whisperer in Darkness | |
| 79 |  | 1931 | At the Mountains of Madness | |
| 80 |  | 1931 | Discarded Draft of The Shadow over Innsmouth | |
| 81 |  | 1931 | The Shadow over Innsmouth | |
| 82 |  | 1931 | The Trap | Henry S Whitehead |
| 83 |  | 1932 | The Dreams in the Witch House | |
| 84 |  | 1932 | The Man of Stone | Hazel Heald |
| 85 |  | 1932 | The Horror in the Museum | Hazel Heald |
| 86 |  | 1932 | Through the Gates of the Silver Key | E Hoffmann Price |
| 87 |  | 1933 | Winged Death | Hazel Heald |
| 88 |  | 1933 | Out of the Aeons | Hazel Heald |
| 89 |  | 1933 | The Thing on the Doorstep | |
| 90 |  | 1933 | The Evil Clergyman | |
| 91 |  | 1933 | The Horror in the Burying-Ground | Hazel Heald |
| 92 |  | 1933 | The Hoard of the Wizard-Beast | R H Barlow |
| 93 |  | 1933 | The Slaying of the Monster | R H Barlow |
| 94 |  | 1933 | The Book | |
| 95 |  | 1934 | The Tree on the Hill | Duane W Rimel |
| 96 |  | 1934 | The Battle that Ended the Century | R H Barlow |
| 97 |  | 1934 | The Shadow out of Time | |
| 98 |  | 1935 | "Till A' the Seas" | R H Barlow |
| 99 |  | 1935 | Collapsing Cosmoses | R H Barlow |
| 100 |  | 1935 | The Challenge from Beyond | C L Moore; A Merritt; Robert E Howard, and Frank Belknap Long |
| 101 |  | 1935 | The Disinterment | Duane W Rimel |
| 102 |  | 1935 | The Diary of Alonzo Typer | William Lumley |
| 103 |  | 1935 | The Haunter of the Dark | |
| 104 |  | 1936 | In the Walls of Eryx | Kenneth Sterling |
| 105 |  | 1936 | The Night Ocean | R H Barlow |